陈耀权律师拥有二十年以上的法律从业经验,已累计代理最高法院民商事诉讼案件超过120件,在复杂疑难民商事诉讼业务领域积累了丰富和独到的执业经验,尤其擅长处理担保、公司、金融、证券、票据、合同、物权等民商事领域的纠纷,代理的大量案件具有填补法律空白的先导性作用,其中有相当部分被收录于《最高人民法院公报》以及《商事审判指导与参考》等最高法院审判业务指导书籍。
陈耀权律师作为天同诉讼业务团队负责人与业务主管,建立并完善的诉讼业务团队工作模式与案件流程管理体系,对于确保为客户提供高效优质的法律服务具有重要意义。
所获奖项
钱伯斯全球(ChambersGlobalGuide)争议解决领域领先律师
钱伯斯亚太(ChambersAsia-PacificGuide)争议解决领域领先律师
亚洲法律事务(ALB)中国十佳诉讼律师
LEGALBAND争议解决(诉讼)领域中国顶级律师
LEGALBAND中国客户指南争议解决领先个人
BenchmarkLitigation亚太商业与交易领域争议解决之星
法律五百强(TheLegal500)争议解决领域杰出律师
《商法》(ChinaBusinessLawJournal)A-List100强精英律师
LCOUNCIL本期采访提纲
1.您和团队有着非常丰富的诉讼代理经验,可以谈一下您是如何帮助客户进行有效的诉讼服务的吗?以及在代理客户诉讼案件的时候与其他律师代理诉讼得核心区别是什么?
陈耀权:我认为要为客户提供有效诉讼服务,其根本方法是对客户真正用心。在用心的基础上,天同的经验主要有四方面:
第一是标准化的业务流程。天同很早就有了41步标准化业务流程,不同分所、不同成员在全国各地为客户提供服务,都坚持着同样流程标准,确保诉讼服务的质量统一。2021年12月,天同内部正式启用了“天工”办案系统,实现了标准化流程的线上协作,同时赋予不同类型案件“因案制宜”的灵活调整空间,更好顺应了现在不同案件类型、不同地域、不同诉讼阶段的差异化需求。这也让天同标准化业务流程在无纸化办公时代具有长久旺盛的生命力。
第二是团队化的作业模式。天同为客户提供诉讼服务时,始终坚持以团队整体提供服务,而非仅指定一名主责人单独办案,更坚决摒弃“大律师接案、小律师办案”的模式。从日常对接模式来说,客户询问承办团队的任何一人,都能准确得到关于案件办理的详细信息,最快速度得到有效响应;从办案质量把控来说,天同内部的互相支持非常充分和高效,可以为了一个复杂疑难案件快速召集全国的核心业务骨干参与“业务委员会”,提供专家式诊断,帮助客户详析诉讼策略。这种团队化的作业模式始终是我们提升客户体验和确保办案质量的重要手段。
第三是有形化的服务内容。诉讼服务虽贯穿于律师团队为客户提供的专业支持全过程中,但却属于无形服务,难以感知。为让客户更加具体、全面了解律师提供的诉讼服务内容,天同始终坚持制定工作计划,并在案件办理多个阶段提供《工作联系函》,将无形服务通过书面形式向客户进行有形化展示。天同相信,诉讼的成功不仅要依靠律师团队的专业支持,当事人与律师的彼此理解、高效沟通亦是最终善果的坚实基础。
至于天同代理诉讼案件的核心优势,我认为天同主要是做好了三件事:
第一,要有取舍。一方面,天同选定了适合自己的业务领域进行深耕,建所20年来,天同基本上只做争议解决,力求在擅长的领域里做到最好,从而有能力为客户提供最可靠、最优质的服务。另一方面,天同也选择为尊重律师工作的客户精心服务,我们坚信,“人和”是成事之本,客户的信赖与认可对案件顺利推进有极其重大的意义,也能让律师的专业实现价值最大化。
第二,真诚是最强大的力量。对案件的认识是什么,能做什么,不能做什么,我们始终与客户坦诚沟通,不虚言、不妄言,秉持真诚之心;同时,我们也不断精进专业能力,敢于下判断、做决断,在每个案件中竭尽全力,真正为客户提供有价值的法律服务方案。
第三,“我们”而非“我”。天同是一个真正的团队,任何一个案件,天同都会集合全所之力去处理,合伙人始终在办案一线,团队每个成员都全心投入,从而充分发挥团队作战的优势;同时,天同也充分认可客户工作人员支持和协助的关键作用,没有客户的配合,律师独木难支,不可能办好案件。只有集合各方可团结的一切力量,全力以赴,方能实现最理想的结果。
陈耀权:我印象很深的是今年刚结案的某国有银行和某上市酒企的侵权责任纠纷再审案件,酒企因存款被犯罪分子诈骗,要求银行赔偿损失,湖南高院判决银行承担全部责任,我们代理银行申请再审,最终改判酒企与银行根据过错大小分担责任。
我们通过深入法理分析,指出行长为谋取个人私利的违法犯罪行为不是职务行为,用人单位对此无法预料、无法避免、无以获利,不应承担替代责任;通过类案检索,指出二审判令银行承担全部责任明显不公,酒企应对本案损失承担与其过错相当的责任。以上意见均被最高法院再审采纳。该案件有很好的启示作用:第一,金融机构一定要定时加强对员工的管理和培训,尽可能避免银行员工以公谋私,导致金融机构承担责任;第二,对于刑民交叉案件,刑事判决结果对于民事案件具有根本影响,因此案发后要尽早介入刑事程序、跟进刑事案件进展,争夺案件管辖权并尽可能在合法范围内争取到有利于自身的刑事判决结果。
其二是担保,担保制度解释颁布两年之际,我们重磅推出了合计十余万字的《公司担保争议解决双年观察》《上市公司担保合规审查指引手册》,聚焦《担保制度解释》颁布两年后规范的体系风貌与实践的百般样态,为未来担保裁判的意见格局提供预判;后者着眼于上市公司担保新规颁布后从裁判视角应对监管要求,全面梳理了担保审议及披露的合规审查操作要点与注意事项,进而能在前端风险防控和后端争议处理为公司法务同仁提供全流程的协助。
陈耀权:大多数诉讼案件的成功,都包含了外部律师和企业法务的共同努力。我们合作过的一些优秀的企业法务,在配合诉讼律师进行诉讼案件管理的过程中都做到了以下几点:
其一,如实充分披露事实情况。选择专业、可信赖的诉讼律师团队,并且给予律师重复的信任,充分披露可能对案件有影响的事实背景和业务情况。
其三,借用案件,改善公司内部风控管理,提升公司治理能力。企业经营发生争议,是非常正常的情况,但每个诉讼仲裁的发生,也是企业经营风险集中爆发的场景。为什么会发生争议、公司管理的薄弱环节发生在哪里,都是优秀法务团队在诉讼过程中经常跟我们探讨的内容,天同也会在案件结案后给客户做一个案件总结,帮助客户更好地改善公司的风险控制,转危为机。
5.可以谈一下您对企业法务内部搭建诉讼团队的建议吗?对于企业法务工作者而言,您觉得在不同的时期,应该分别具备什么样的能力?
陈耀权:企业内部是否搭建诉讼团队、如何搭建团队,要视乎有多少诉讼案件以及以何种类型的案件为主。不少企业的法务部编制不多,尤其是在企业利润有限的情况下,要求公司增加更多的人员编制可能有困难。但无论什么时期,懂得与内外部伙伴良好沟通、充分合作的法务工作者,都能获得成功。
6.您在业界取得过非常多的荣誉,其中就包含钱伯斯全球(ChambersGlobalGuide)争议解决领域领先律师、钱伯斯亚太(ChambersAsia-PacificGuide)争议解决领域领先律师等荣誉,可以谈一下您获得各项殊荣的感触以及对未来工作的展望吗?
陈耀权:我认为获得这些荣誉的根本原因在于天同及我本人二十年来在争议解决领域的专注与坚守,但更离不开客户的信任,离不开天同同事的默默付出。我一直说所有荣誉属于全体天同人。当然因各种原因,还有很大优秀的同行未能上榜,他们也应受到同等尊重。未来,我们将坚持做难而正确的事,坚守高度一体化,深扎争议解决之根,坚持专业领先,相信专业制胜;不断探索新领域、捕捉新趋势、提炼新思考,扩展专业极致的内涵与外延。
7.您跟LCOUNCIL有过初次的合作了,可以谈一下您跟LCOUNCIL合作之初,以及合作之后的感触吗,对LCOUNCL有着怎样的评价?
陈耀权:LCOUNCIL作为一家专业成熟的体系化法律培训平台,其最大的特点体现充分挖掘了法律共同体的互惠性、成长性。一方面,就知识层面,LCOUNCIL能够精准识别法律人对解决各领域实务疑难及热点的需求,及时匹配该领域的专家进行答疑解惑;另一方面,就业务层面,基于平台点对面的宣传,让“术业有专攻”的专业人员有机会发现并化解处处寻医问药的“疑难杂症”,进而实现双赢。
LCOUNCIL走近天同律师事务所
天同律师事务所成立于2002年,致力于在重大复杂商事争议解决领域,成为最可信赖、最受尊重的伟大律师事务所。建所至今,天同一直坚持“不求最大,但求最精、最专”的理念,遵循“在最擅长的领域做到最好”的发展战略,为客户提供“诉讼+仲裁+执行+破产”四位一体的全流程服务,最大限度保障客户的合法权益。
天同拥有专业、高效的律师团队,基于模拟法庭、诉讼可视化、案例大数据等现代诉讼技术和手段,在各级人民法院(尤其是高级人民法院及以上)及主要仲裁机构有着令人称羡的出色成绩。天同代理的案件中逾40件收录于《最高人民法院公报》《商事审判指导》《民事审判指导与参考》《立案工作指导与参考》《审判监督指导》等民商事审判核心刊物,部分案件更是被最高人民法院确立为指导案例,在民商事审判领域发挥指引作用。
天同广受业界及客户认可,分别在2021年和2016年荣获司法部和全国律协颁发的“全国优秀律师事务所”称号。同时,多次荣获钱伯斯争议解决领先律所、TheLegal500争议解决领先律师事务所、亚洲法律杂志(AsianLegalBusiness,ALB)年度诉讼律师事务所、AsialawProfiles争议解决高度推荐律师事务所、LEGALBAND争议解决领先律师事务所、《商法》(ChinaBusinessLawJournal,CBLJ)年度争议解决卓越律所等奖项。
LCOUNCILProfileofthecurrentissue
ChenYaoquan
TianTongShenzhenlawfirm,foundingpartner,directorofShenzhenBranchOffice
ChenYaoquanhasmorethan20yearsoflegalpracticeexperienceandhasrepresentedmorethan120civilandcommerciallitigationcasesintheSupremeCourt.Hehasaccumulatedrichanduniquepracticeexperienceinthefieldofcomplexanddifficultcivilandcommerciallitigation.Inparticular,heisgoodatdealingwithdisputesincivilandcommercialareassuchasguarantee,company,finance,securities,bills,contracts,propertyrights,etc,andhasaleadingroleinfillingthelegalgapsinalargenumberofcases,TheyhavebeenincludedintheSupremePeople'sCourtGazette,GuidanceandReferenceonCommercialTrialandotherSupremeCourttrialbusinessguidancebooks.
CommercialLaw(ChinaBusinessLawJournal)A-List100StrongEliteLawyers.
AstheheadandbusinessdirectorofTiantong'slitigationpracticeteam,ChenYaoquanhasestablishedandimprovedthelitigationpracticeteam'sworkmodelandcaseprocessmanagementsystem,whichisofgreatsignificancetoensurethatweprovideefficientandhigh-qualitylegalservicestoourclients.
Awardsreceived.
ChambersGlobalGuideLeadingLawyersinDisputeResolution
ChambersAsia-PacificGuideLeadingLawyersinDisputeResolution
AlbemarleChina'sTop10Litigators
LEGALBANDTopLawyersinChinainDisputeResolution(Litigation)
LEGALBANDChinaCustomerGuideDisputeResolutionLeadingIndividual
BenchmarkLitigationAsiaPacificBusiness&TransactionDisputeResolutionStar
TheLegal500LawyersinDisputeResolution
CommercialLaw(ChinaBusinessLawJournal)A-List100StrongEliteLawyers
LCOUNCILanoutlineofthisinterview
Youandyourteamhavealotofexperienceinlitigationrepresentation.CanyoutalkabouthowyouhelpyourclientscarryouteffectivelitigationservicesAndwhatisthecoredifferencebetweenyouandotherlawyerswhenrepresentingclients
ChenYaoquan:Personally,thefundamentalmethodtoprovideefficientlitigationservicesistobetrulyattentivetoclients.Basedonwhich,Tiantonghasfouraspectsofexperiencestosharewithyou.
First,thestandardizedbusinessprocess.Tiantonghashada41-stepstandardizedbusinessprocessfromearlyon,towhichdifferentbranchesandmembersallassiduouslystick,ensuringthatthelitigationservicesofhighanduniformqualitycanbeprovided.InDecemberof2012,Tiantongofficiallylaunched"Tiangong"internalcase-handlingsystemandachievedtheonlinecollaborationofthestandardizedprocess.Accordingly,differenttypesofcasesareleftflexibleroomforadjustmentbasedoncase-specificprinciple,whichbettercaterstothevariousneedsincasesofdifferentcategories,regions,andstagesinthelitigation.Inreturn,thisbestowsfullandlong-lastingvitalityonTiantong’sstandardizedbusinessprocessintheeraofpaperlessofficework.
Second,theteam-basedoperationmode.WhenTiantongprovideslitigationservicesforclients,italwaysinsistsonprovidingservicesasawholeteam,insteadofdesignatingonlyoneprincipaltohandlethecase,letalonethemodethat"biglawyeracceptsthecase,smalllawyerhandlesthecase".Fromtheaspectofdailycommunication,nomatterwhichundertakertheclientinquiries,theclientcanreceiveeffectiveresponseatthefastestspeed,withtheaccurateanddetailedinformationaboutthecase.Intermsofqualitycontrolofcase-handling,colleaguesoffersufficientandefficientsupportmutuallyinsideTiantong.Inordertosolveacomplicatedanddifficultcase,wecanquicklyconveneallthecorebackbonestoparticipateinthe"businesscommittee",toprovideexpertdiagnosisandanalyzethelitigationstrategyindetail.Thiskindofteam-basedoperationmodealwaysservesasanimportantmeansforustoenhancetheexperienceofclientandensurethequalityofservice.
Third,thevisualizationofservices.Generally,thelitigationservicespenetrateintothewholeprocessofprofessionalsupportprovidedbylawyerstoclients,buttheyareintangibleanddifficulttoperceive.Toensurethatclientshavemorespecificandcomprehensiveunderstandingofthelitigationservices,Tiantongalwaysdevelopsworkplans,providesContactLetteratmultiplestages,visualizingtheintangibleserviceinwriting.Tiantongstronglybelieves,thesuccessoflitigationnotonlydependsontheprofessionalsupportofitslegalteam,butalsoonthemutualunderstandingandefficientcommunicationbetweentheclientsandtheirlawyers.
Fourth,themootcourt.Foreveryimportantcase,Tiantong’slegalteamwillconductinternalrehearsalsbeforethetrial,tosimulateallpossibleviewpointsinthetrial,andpolishthetrialschemeaccordingly.Thisprocesshelpsusbetteradapttotherealstateofthetrial,testslitigationstrategiesfromdifferentanglesandpreparescorrespondingplans.Moreover,thisensureslawyerscanrespondtoallkindsofunexpectedsituationsmorecalmlyandcomprehensivelyinrealtrial,effectivelyoutputkeyargumentsinthelimitedtimeallowedbythecourt,andeventuallyfightforthewinningofthelawsuits.
Tiantonghasthreecoreadvantagesastoitsrepresentationinlitigations.
First,theremustbetrade-offs.Ontheonehand,Tiantonghasselectedthebusinessfieldsuitableforitslong-termcommitment.Sincethislawfirmwasestablished20yearsago,Tiantonghasbeenbasicallyspecializedindisputeresolution,strivingtodothebestinthisfield,whichmakesitcapabletoprovideclientswiththemostreliableandhigh-qualityservices.Ontheotherhand,Tiantongalsochoosestheclientswhorespectthelawyers’worktoprovidemeticulousservices.Wefirmlybelievethataharmoniousrelationshipisthefoundationofsuccess,theclients’trustandrecognitionareofgreatsignificanceforthecasetoproceedsmoothly,whichcanalsomaximizethevalueoflawyers'profession.
Second,sincerityisthegreatestpower.Whencommunicatingwithclients,wearealwayshonestaboutwhatweknowaboutthecase,whatwecandoandcannotdo,weneverboastaboutourselves.Atthesametime,wekeepimprovingourexpertise,daretomakejudgmentsanddecisions,andtryouroutmostineverycasetoprovideclientswithvaluablelegalservices.
Third,itisallabout"us"ratherthan"me".Tiantongisacloselyconnectedidealteam.Foranycase,Tiantongwillexertitsfulleffortstodealwithit,ourpartnersarealwaysonthefrontlineofhandlingcases,workingtogetherwitheachcommittedmembers,totakefulladvantagesoftheteamcollaboration.Meanwhile,Tiantongalsorecognizesthekeyroleofclients’supportandassistance,withoutwhichourlawyercouldnothandlethecaseswellonlybyourselves.Onlyifwegatheralltheunitableforces,endeavortodoourbestwithotherparties,canwemakeourdesirescometrue.
Amongthemanysuccessfulcasesyouhaverepresented,canyoutellusaboutthemostchallengingandimpressiverelatedcases,andwhatkeydetailsintheprocessoflitigationcanarousethevigilanceofourcolleaguesintheLegalDepartment
ChenYaoquan:Iwouldliketosharetheretrialcasethatwasjustclosedinthisyearwithyou,itwasaboutthetortliabilitydisputebetweenastate-ownedbankandalistedliquorcompany.Inthiscase,theliquorcompanywasdefraudedbycriminalswhosneakeditsdepositinthebankaway,andthecompanyaskedthebanktocompensateforitslosses.TheHunanHigherCourtheldthatthebankshouldbearalltheresponsibilities.Weappliedforretrialonbehalfofthebank,andtheSupremeCourtfinallydecidedthatbothoftheliquorcompanyandthebankshouldsharetheresponsibilitiesaccordingtothedegreesoftheirfault.
Youandyourteamhaveachievedalotofhonorsandachievementsintheindustry,doyouhaveanyimportantprofessionalachievementstosharewithusthisyearHowwillthishelpourlegalcolleaguesintheirwork
ChenYaoquan:Thisyear,Ihaveledmyteamtodeveloptwoseriesofproductchainbasedontheexpertise,experienceandstrategy,bothofwhichhaveyieldedremarkableoutcomes.Thefirstoneisaboutretrial.RetrialisTiantong‘slineofwork,IalsohaveextensiveexperiencesinrepresentingretrialcasesbeforeSupremePeople’sCourtandHigherPeople'sCourts,andIamelectedasthedirectorofretrialcommitteeofGuangdongLawyersAssociation.Therefore,basedonpracticaldifficultiesandjudicialcharacteristicsofthestatusquo,ourteamhascomprehensivelysummarizedasystematicpracticalguideline,coveringfourdimensionsofretrialapplicants,retrialobjects,retrialmaterialspreparationandotherproceduralissues.OnDecember10and24in2022,Iwasinvitedtosharemyexperienceaswellastheanalysisofmajoranddifficultproblemsinretrialprocedure,respectivelyintheseminarshostedbyretrialcommitteeofGuangdongLawyersAssociationandprofessionalcommitteeofcivillawofHunanLawyersAssociation.Thelectureswerewatchedandwidelyacclaimedbymorethan60,000peopleonline.
Thesecondisanchoredinguaranteedsphere.Inthesecondyearafterthepromulgationof“InterpretationoftheSupremePeople'sCourtoftheApplicationoftheRelevantGuaranteeSystemoftheCivilCodeofthePeople'sRepublicofChina”,werollout“BiennialObservationonDisputeResolutionofCorporateGuarantee”and“ManualofGuidanceonComplianceReviewofGuaranteebyListedCompanies(SecondEdition)”,whichadduptoover100,000words.Theformerfocusesontheestablishingsystemoflegalrulesandconstruingvariationofcasepractices,inabidtoprovideprejudgmentofthefuturejudicialdecisions.Thelatterlayspressonhowtocomplywithregulatoryrequirementsfromthejudiciaryperspective,sortsthroughthekeypointsandprecautionsforcompliancereviewofguaranteedresolutionanddisclosure.Accordingly,wecanfullyassistthein-houselawyersinthewholeprocessoffront-endriskpreventionandback-enddisputeresolution.
Weknowthatanyclient'scaserequirescloseandefficientcooperationbetweenourcorporatelegalteamandourexternallawyers.CanyoutalkaboutwhatthecorporatelegaldepartmentneedstopayattentiontointheprocessoflitigationcasemanagementwithlitigationlawyersWhataretherelevantlitigationskillsandmeanstoteach
ChenYaoquan:Thesuccessofmostlitigationcasescanbeattributedtothejointeffortsofexternallawyersandcorporatelegalcounsels.Basedonourpriorcooperationexperienceswithsomeofexcellentcorporatelegalcounsels,wewouldsummarizetheirthreeadvantagesincasemanagement:
First,theyfullydisclosethecasefacts.Afterselectingaprofessionalandreliableteamoflitigationlawyers,theygiverepeatedtrustandfullyinformthefactualbackgroundandbusinessconditionsthatmayhaveanimpactonthecase.
Second,theycantimelyfindoutrelevantevidencewithinthecompanyaccordingtothelawyer'ssuggestion.Theevidenceofbusinessisusuallycontrolledbypersonnelsoffinance,business,customerservice,salesmanagementandotherdepartments,butthecompetentlegaldepartmentscancoordinatewithcolleaguesinotherdepartmentstogatherevidence.Iftheevidenceisfavorabletothecompany,itcanhelprealizethelitigationclaim;Ifitisnot,thelawyercanalsopreparearesponseplaninadvance.
Third,theycanimprovetheinternalmanagementofriskcontrolaswellasthecompany'sgovernanceabilityinvirtueofthecases.Itiscommonplaceforanenterprisetogetinvolvedindisputesarisingfromtheirbusiness,andtheoccurrenceofeachlawsuitandarbitrationrevealsthetypicalscenewereoperationriskoutbreaksintensively.Duringthelitigationprocess,outstandingin-houselawyersusuallydiscusswithuswhythedisputestakeplaceandwherearetheweaklinksofthecompany'smanagement.Inthemeantime,Tiantongwillalsomakeacasesummaryafterthecaseisclosed,assistingtheclienttobetterimprovethecompany'sriskcontrolandturntheadversityintoanopportunity.
CanyoutalkaboutyoursuggestiontobuildalitigationteamwithincorporatelegalForcorporatelegalworkers,whatkindofcapabilitiesdoyouthinktheyshouldhaveatdifferenttimes
ChenYaoquan:Whetherandhowtobuildaninternallitigationteamdependsonthenumberandtypesoflitigationcasesthisenterprisegetsinvolved.Manyenterpriseshaveasmall-sizedlegaldepartment,especiallyinthecaseoflimitedprofits,soitmaybeunrealistictorequiremorelegalstuff.However,atanytime,legalcounselswhoknowhowtocommunicateandcooperatewellwithinternalandexternalpartnerscanachievesuccess.
Legalcounselsareobligedtosolvelegalissuesinvolvingallaspectsofthecompany'soperation,justlikethefamilydoctorofanenterprise.Tosomeextent,in-houselawyersaresimilartogeneralpractitioners,whereasexternallawyersarespecialistdoctors,bothareessential.Goodgeneralpractitionersnotonlyhelpwithdailyprevention,diagnosis,treatmentandhealthcare,butalsomatchthemostsuitablespecialistintheindustryatthefirsttimewhenahigh-risksituationoccurs,sothatspecialistscanidentifyillnessinatimelymannerwithoutdelay.Ifthelegalcounselscanassistinenterprise’sfullrehabilitationafterthesurgery,thentheyhaverealizeditsvalueofsupportingandescortingthecompanytodevelophealthily.
Youhaveachievedalotofhonorintheindustry,AmongthemareChambersGlobalGuide'sleadinglawyerindisputeresolutionandChambersAsia-PacificGuide'sleadinglawyerindisputeresolution.Canyoutalkaboutyourfeelingsaboutwinningtheawardsandyouroutlookforthefuture
ChenYaoquan:Frommyperspective,thefundamentalreasonforattainingthesehonorsliesinthefocusandperseveranceofTiantongandmyselfinthedomainofdisputeresolutionoverthepast20years,whichisinseparablefromtheclients’deeptrustandthecolleagues’unknowncontribution.AsIalwayssay,allhonorsbelongtoallTiantongmembers.Ofcourse,duetovariousreasons,therearemanyoutstandingpeerswhohavenotbeenlistedintheranking,theyshouldalsobeequallyrespected.Inthefuture,wewillsticktothedifficultandcorrecttrackwiththehighlevelofintegration,getdeeplyrootedindisputeresolution;wewillmaintainourprofessionalleadership,andfirmlybelieveinthatprofessioncanleadtovictory;wewillconstantlyexplorenewspheres,catchnewtrends,refinenewthinking,andexpandtheconnotationandextensionofprofessionalexcellence.
YouhavecooperatedwithLCOUNCILforthefirsttime.CanyoutalkaboutyourfeelingsatthebeginningandafterthecooperationwithLCOUNCIL,andhowdoyouevaluateLCOUNCIL
ChenYaoquan:Asaprofessionalandmaturelegaltrainingplatform,LCOUNCIL'slargestcharacteristicisthatitfullyexcavatesthereciprocityoflegalcommunity.Ontheonehand,intermsofknowledge,LCOUNCILcanaccuratelyidentifylegalpractitioners’needstoresolvedifficultandhotspotissuesinvariousspheres,andthereforeinvitecorrespondingexpertstoanswertheirquestionsintime.Ontheotherhand,concerningpromotingbusinessoflegalservices,LCOUNCILfullymakesusageofitsadvertisingfunction,makingiteasierfortheexpertstodiscoverandresolvepuzzleswithintheirareasofexpertiseandthusachieveawin-winsituation.
LCOUNCILapproachtheTiantonglawfirm.
Foundedin2002,TiantongLawFirmiscommittedtobecomingthemosttrustedandrespectedgreatlawfirminthefieldofmajorandcomplexcommercialdisputeresolution.Tothisday,Tiantonghasalwaysadheredtotheconceptof"notseekingthegreatest,butthemostrefinedandmostexclusive."Followingthedevelopmentstrategyof"doingthebestinthebestfield,"weprovidecustomerswith"litigation+arbitration+enforcement+bankruptcy"four-in-onefull-processservicestomaximizetheprotectionofcustomers'legitimaterightsandinterests.
Tiantonghasaprofessionalandefficientteamoflawyers,basedonmootcourt,litigationvisualization,casebigdataandothermodernlitigationtechnologyandmeans,Inthepeople'scourtsatalllevels(especiallythehigherpeople'scourtsandabove)andthemainarbitrationinstitutionshaveenviableoutstandingresults.Morethan40ofthecaseshandledbyTiantongwereincludedintheGazetteoftheSupremePeople'sCourt,CommercialTrialGuidance,CivilTrialGuidanceandReference,GuidanceandReferenceforCase-filingWork,andTrialSupervisionGuidance,amongothercorepublicationsoncivilandcommercialtrials.SomecaseshavebeenestablishedasguidingcasesbytheSupremePeople'sCourt,whichplaysaguidingroleinthefieldofcivilandcommercialtrial.
Withthemissionofparticipatinginbuildingafairerandmorejustlegalecosystem,TiantongestablishedWeChat,oneofthemostinfluentiallegalprofessionalswe-mediainChina,in2014.OfficialAccountmessagetemplate“TiantongLitigationCircle”,continuetoshareoriginalprofessionalarticles,spreadthepositiveenergyoflitigation,hasmorethan550thousandsubscribers.Inthepasttenyears,Tiantonghasusedthekey-codeencodingmethodofBritishandAmericancaselawcountriesforreference,collected,combedandrefinedtherulesofjudicialprecedent,andformedaseriesofbookswith42millioncharacters,creatingauniquecaseencodingsysteminChina.
Tiantongiswidelyrecognizedbytheindustryandcustomersandwasawardedthetitleof"NationalExcellentLawFirm"bytheMinistryofJusticeandtheChinaLawyersAssociationin2021and2016respectively.Atthesametime,ChambersLeadingLawFirminDisputeResolution,TheLegal500LeadingLawFirminDisputeResolution,AsianLegalMagazine(AsianLegalBusiness,Albemarle)LitigationLawFirmoftheYear,AsialawProfilesHighlyRecommendedLawFirmforDisputeResolution,LEGALBANDLeadingLawFirmforDisputeResolution,BusinessLaw(ChinaBusinessLawJournal,CBLJ)DisputeResolutionFirmoftheYearandotherawards.
过往LCOUNCIL曾多次与天同深圳律师事务所创始合伙人陈耀权律师合作举办线上主题研讨会议,扫描下方二维码申请往期直播免费回看!